Another Crank Trigger Option?

Discuss VEMS and other standalone ECUs
Post Reply
GTJeff
Posts: 101
Joined: Mon Apr 08, 2013 2:52 pm

Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by GTJeff »

Anybody use a flying magnet crank or cam trigger setup on a 5 cyl?

I am using a hall sensor with 3 magnets embeded in the crank pulley on my Alfa V6. I think you could do a similar setup on a 5 cylinder but you would obviously need to install 5 magnets in the crank pulley for two pulses cycle. Then just use a single window dizzy for cam sync. Or maybe it would be easier and a decent compromise to implement it on the cam pulley.

This is an SDS hall sensor with trigger magnets embedded (epoxied) into the back of the crank pulley which I am going to use with MS2. http://www.sdsefi.com/EM5E20.pdf
Attachments
2014-11-06 21.36.24.jpg
2014-11-06 21.36.24.jpg (95.14 KiB) Viewed 28950 times
User avatar
bradyzq
Posts: 115
Joined: Sun Jun 02, 2013 5:51 pm
Location: Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Contact:

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by bradyzq »

It won't work with 5 magnets on the crank. Calculate TDC for each piston and you'll see why.

It would work on the cam, but is no better resolution-wise than a 5 window distributor. That is the bare minimum resolution to make a 5 cylinder run.
Cheers, Brady
83 urq, 034 IIc'ed..[][] oooo [][] 150whp
86 4kq, MS'n'S'ed.......O O oooo O O 80whp
91 200qa20v,.......[++] oooo [++] 166whp
72 240Z 123whp
www.dynodoc.ca
jretal
Posts: 482
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2013 11:57 am

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by jretal »

I guess another question that popped through my head - could you machine the teeth for a 60-2 wheel on the crank pulley itself? Similar idea to the flywheel? Would potential movement/deflection of the outter ring cause issues?
GTJeff
Posts: 101
Joined: Mon Apr 08, 2013 2:52 pm

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by GTJeff »

Ok, so please educate me if I am missing something and not thinking about this correctly but I think that it would work if used with a cam sensor. I also think that it would work without a cam sensor with wasted spark ignition and two injector pulses per rev.
Attachments
Capture.JPG
Capture.JPG (26.8 KiB) Viewed 28929 times
User avatar
audifreakjim
Posts: 2142
Joined: Sun Mar 03, 2013 3:00 pm

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by audifreakjim »

jretal wrote:I guess another question that popped through my head - could you machine the teeth for a 60-2 wheel on the crank pulley itself? Similar idea to the flywheel? Would potential movement/deflection of the outter ring cause issues?


It's been done, but the outer ring does move around quite a bit, and has been known to slip over time.

I still think the rear crank seal trigger is pretty slick. It's probably a weekend project, but you will have a no non-sense solution and you don't have to buy a new flywheel.
User avatar
Mcstiff
Posts: 2003
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 4:16 pm
Location: Erie, CO

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by Mcstiff »

Figured I'd whore out the 90's crank trigger, even if the pulley is a bit different (still looks 2 pc). If/when I build a urI5 I'd go for the RMS trigger Jimmy mentioned.

Image
jretal
Posts: 482
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2013 11:57 am

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by jretal »

audifreakjim wrote:
jretal wrote:I guess another question that popped through my head - could you machine the teeth for a 60-2 wheel on the crank pulley itself? Similar idea to the flywheel? Would potential movement/deflection of the outter ring cause issues?


It's been done, but the outer ring does move around quite a bit, and has been known to slip over time.

I still think the rear crank seal trigger is pretty slick. It's probably a weekend project, but you will have a no non-sense solution and you don't have to buy a new flywheel.


Ah, the walk is a good call, Jim - wasn't thinking about that.

The rear crank seal trigger is very slick, but don't those have issues from time to time too? Or am I off on that? Not sure where I'm getting that from, so my thoughts could be off-base.
DE80q
Posts: 2572
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2013 9:25 am
Location: York PA 17403

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by DE80q »

My plan is to buy a NG flywheel and cut a 60-2 trigger pattern into the outer edge of it. I know this is not a viable option for some, but with the MegaSquirt setup I have, this solution should work perfectly.
"If you can't find one, make one"

Dallastown, PA
1991 Audi 80 quattro (20vt project)
1991 Audi Coupe Quattro (project: my first 20v)
2007 Mitsubishi Raider(Dakota in disguise)
2019 Chevy Cruze RS hatch (wife's little red sporty car)
User avatar
vt10vt
Posts: 1021
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 9:44 pm
Location: Winooski, VT

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by vt10vt »

DE80q wrote:My plan is to buy a NG flywheel and cut a 60-2 trigger pattern into the outer edge of it. I know this is not a viable option for some, but with the MegaSquirt setup I have, this solution should work perfectly.

Yeah or just use any of the thousands of flywheels Audi cut a 60-2 into to begin with.

Custom cutting one is deff easier tho.
-Shawn C.
2001 S4 6spd Avant blk/blk - stock daily
2002 01E B6 A4 Built FYF, Built 1.8T, HX35 ~330whp
1989 MC-1 200 Avant- MS1 -Gone but will never forget her lessons
1987 5ktq Sedan - Best $500 beater ever
DE80q
Posts: 2572
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2013 9:25 am
Location: York PA 17403

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by DE80q »

vt10vt wrote:
DE80q wrote:My plan is to buy a NG flywheel and cut a 60-2 trigger pattern into the outer edge of it. I know this is not a viable option for some, but with the MegaSquirt setup I have, this solution should work perfectly.

Yeah or just use any of the thousands of flywheels Audi cut a 60-2 into to begin with.

Custom cutting one is deff easier tho.

Is there a factory I5 single mass flywheels for the 01a/e with a 60-2 trigger cut into it? I know some of the newer flywheels have them.
"If you can't find one, make one"

Dallastown, PA
1991 Audi 80 quattro (20vt project)
1991 Audi Coupe Quattro (project: my first 20v)
2007 Mitsubishi Raider(Dakota in disguise)
2019 Chevy Cruze RS hatch (wife's little red sporty car)
User avatar
audifreakjim
Posts: 2142
Joined: Sun Mar 03, 2013 3:00 pm

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by audifreakjim »

I have this setup for sale, $1250 fixes all of your problems.
Image
DE80q
Posts: 2572
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2013 9:25 am
Location: York PA 17403

Re: Another Crank Trigger Option?

Post by DE80q »

audifreakjim wrote:I have this setup for sale, $1250 fixes all of your problems.
Image

That would solve the trigger issue yes. I''m pretty sure that's a little way too much clutch for my "tractor engine" 20vt. Nice setup though.
"If you can't find one, make one"

Dallastown, PA
1991 Audi 80 quattro (20vt project)
1991 Audi Coupe Quattro (project: my first 20v)
2007 Mitsubishi Raider(Dakota in disguise)
2019 Chevy Cruze RS hatch (wife's little red sporty car)
Post Reply